terça-feira, 4 de outubro de 2016

9.ago.2016 - Fósseis de 2 mil anos atrás achados na última semana na Sérvia causam um mistério entre cientistas. Juntos aos restos humanos, pesquisadores encontraram dois amuletos de chumbo que continham dentro rolos de metais preciosos - ouro e prata - cobertos de símbolos e escritos. Entre os escritos, em aramaico, estão nomes de demônios conectados ao atual território da Síria. Os arqueólogos acreditam que os escritos sejam feitiços - magias eram enterradas com corpos que sofreram mortes violents.


15.set.2016 - Pesquisadores da Universidade George Washington (EUA) identificaram um tecido azul-índigo de 6.200 anos, em Huaca, no Peru. O pano pode ser reconhecido como a mais antiga peça de algodão azul índigo, uma cor tecnicamente desafiadora de produzir. A cor, que ficou famosa com o nascimento dos jeans por volta de 1890, era produzida através da extração de uma planta chamada Indigofera suffruticos. A produção sintética do índigo só foi possível a partir de 1880 por meio das pesquisas do químico alemão Adolf von Baeyer, que recebeu o Nobel da Química por esse feito.


O SENHOR DOS ANÉIS - O túmulo descoberto por pesquisadores da Universidade do Cincinnati na cidade de Pilos possui mais de 3.500 anos. O homem enterrado no local por volta de 1.500 a.C. pode ter sido um guerreiro ou um padre de cerca de 30 anos. Ao seu redor estavam mais de 2.000 objetos, incluindo quatro anéis de ouro sólido, taças de prata, pérolas, pentes de marfim, uma espada, dentre outros. Um dos anéis (foto) é o segundo maior com sinete de ouro já descoberto na região do mar Egeu. Ele mostra cinco figuras femininas reunidas em um santuário à beira do mar. Já o esqueleto foi apelidado de "guerreiro grifo", devido à presença de uma placa de marfim decorada com o animal mítico com corpo de leão e cabeça e asas de águia.

O SENHOR DOS ANÉIS - Uma descoberta rara de um túmulo intacto repleto de artefatos da Era do Bronze pode mudar o que se conhece sobre a história da Grécia. O local onde foi enterrado há cerca de 3500 anos um guerreiro da época áurea da civilização creto-micênica, que antecede a civilização grega, continha joias preciosas, armas, espelhos (foto) e outras riquezas com características que remetem aos minóicos, civilização de cultura ainda mais antiga. Até então, pensava-se que riquezas dos minóicos tinham sido roubadas no momento em que foram conquistados pelos micênicos na ilha de Creta. O achado, contudo, indica uma troca cultural e uma convivência mais ampla entre as duas culturas, lançando novo olhar sobre a civilização micênica, base da civilização grega.
9.ago.2016 - Arqueólogos trabalham no sítio de Viminacium, na Sérvia. Os cientistas estão tentando decifrar feitiços mágicos gravados em pequenos rolos de ouro e prata, que eles encontraram ao lado de esqueletos de seres humanos enterrados há quase 2.000 anos. Segundo os especialistas a inscrições estão em aramaico.

4.ago.2016 - Um grupo de cientistas encontrou provas de uma grande inundação ocorrida há 4.000 anos no vale do rio Amarelo dariam veracidade ao mito de fundação da primeira dinastia chinesa, a Xia, segundo um estudo divulgado pela revista "Science". De acordo com essa lenda de fundação, o criador da dinastia Xia, o imperador Yu, teria drenado as águas inundadas habilitando assim as terras para a agricultura e dando início à civilização chinesa.
1º.ago.2016 - Ao menos 80 esqueletos foram encontrados em uma vala comum no antigo cemitério grego em Falyron Delta, Atenas. Os pulsos dos esqueletos estão presos por algemas de ferro. Arqueólogos dizem que todos foram vítimas de uma execução em massa, mas o motivo é um mistério. "Eles foram executados da mesma maneira, eram jovens e saudáveis", afirmou à Reuters Stella Chyssoulaki, chefe das escavações. Testes de DNA serão feitos para estudar os esqueletos. Especialistas suspeitam que eles são vítimas de uma tentativa frustrada de golpe de estadoImagem: Alkis Konstantinidis/ Reuters.

Pesquisador afirma que rastros deixados por dinossauros na Bolívia não existem em outros lugares do mundo.

27.jul.2016 - O paleontólogo Sebastian Apesteguia mede uma pegada feita por um dinossauro carnívoro há 80 milhões de anos. A pegada de 1,20 metro de diâmetro foi encontrada na cratera de Maragua, na Bolívia.
10.jul.2016 - Pesquisadores em Israel afirmam ter descoberto um cemitério filisteu - seria, segundo eles, o primeiro a ser encontrado na história. O achado, ocorrido em 2013 e tornado público neste domingo (10), pode trazer respostas sobre o antigo mistério em torno da origem do povoImagem: Gil Cohen Magen/Xinhua.

10.jul.2016 - Pesquisadores em Israel afirmam ter descoberto um cemitério filisteu - seria, segundo eles, o primeiro a ser encontrado na história. O achado, ocorrido em 2013 e tornado público neste domingo, pode trazer respostas sobre o antigo mistério em torno da origem do povo.

8.jul.2016 - Arqueólogos encontraram no sítio de Tlailotlacan uma das ossadas mais completas do período pré-colombiano nas Américas. A chamada 'mulher de Tlailotlacana teria vivido há cerca de 1600 anos e pertencia à civilização maia.

7.jun.2016 - Arqueólogos encontraram restos mortais no local de um massacre ocorrido há 6.000 anos, em Achenheim, na Alsácia, na França. Funcionários do Instituto Nacional de Investigação Arqueológica Preventiva acreditam que os esqueletos sejam de um conflito entre recém-chegados à área. Segundo os arqueólogos, as fraturas encontradas nos esqueletos indicam que não se trata de ferimentos de batalha, mas de uma execução violenta.

HUMANOS HÁ 11 MIL ANOS EM SP - Descoberta arqueológica no interior de São Paulo pode apimentar o debate sobre a presença de povos na América. A datação de pedras lascadas de um sítio de São Manuel, no interior, feita por um laboratório americano aponta que os objetos são de 11 mil anos atrás. Os itens entram para a lista de objetos mais antigos já achados no Brasil, que variam no mesmo período - datações muito mais antigas do que esta são vistas com ceticismo por cientistas.

Mais um dos mistérios que envolvem o faraó Tutancâmon foi desvendado. Segundo uma pesquisa publicada na revista norte-americana "Meteoritics e Planetary Science", o punhal encontrado junto a múmia foi, de fato, feito com material vindo de um meteorito. Desde 1925, cientistas tentam comprovar as "lendas" egípcias que citavam o "ferro que caiu do céu". Agora testes científicos feitos com técnicas de fluorescência de raios X indicaram que a lâmina contém 10% de níquel e 0,6% de cobalto, concentrações de substâncias encontradas em meteoritos metálicos.

24.mai.2016 - Arqueólogos da Universidade Stanford escavaram ao longo do rio Wei, na China, e acharam equipamentos para fabricação de cerveja. Incluindo este funil.
18.mai.2016 - Ossos fossilizados de um mamute ficam expostos em local de escavação do INAH (Instituto Nacional de Antropologia e História do México). Os fósseis datam do Pleistoceno e foram descobertos em dezembro de 2015 por trabalhadores enquanto cavavam uma fossa séptica. A foto da descoberta foi divulgada pelo INAH na quarta-feira (18).

22.abr.2016 - Arqueólogos estudam tampa de urna funerária em sítio arqueológico, em São José dos Campos, em São Paulo. A peça foi encontrada em local pertencente a tribo tupi-guarani.



Um enorme dente de cachalote foi achado em uma praia em Beaumaris Bay, perto de Melbourne (Austrália). O dente fossilizado mede 30 cm e teria 5 milhões de anos.
 
4.abr.2016 - Arqueólogos descobriram restos humanos antigos e diversas práticas funerárias em um dos lugares mais misteriosos da Ásia, a Planície dos Jarros na província de Xieng Khouang, em Laos. Os pesquisadores pretendem descobrir a razão dos corpos estarem enterrados ao lado de frascos. Este será o primeiro grande esforço desde 1930 para tentar entender o propósito do uso dos recipientes.
 
26.fev.2016 - A UFTM (Universidade Federal do Triângulo Mineiro) recebeu fósseis de 400 milhões de anos encontrados no Brasil. A universidade avaliará os objetos, que são oriundos do Programa de Monitoramento e Salvamento Paleontológico e foram achados em regiões que compreendem do Mato Grosso ao Triângulo Mineiro. Os fósseis, de origem animal, estão em 86 blocos de pedra.
 
Imagem mostra crânio com traços de afundamento, encontrado perto do lago Turkana, no Quênia, em um local chamado Nataruk. Cientistas afirmaram que o esqueleto corresponde a evidência mais antiga de uma guerra. O fóssil faz parte de um grupo de pessoas massacradas, mortas por ataques de flecha e lâminas de pedra há cerca de 10 mil anos.
 
20.jan.2016 - O esqueleto de um homem foi encontrado deitado no sedimento de uma lagoa a 30 km a oeste do Lago Turkana, no Quênia, em um local chamado Nataruk. Ele tinha sinais de múltiplas lesões na parte da frente e no lado esquerdo dele. Cientistas afirmaram que o esqueleto corresponde a evidência mais antiga de uma guerra. O fóssil faz parte de um grupo de pessoas massacradas, mortas por ataques de flecha e lâminas de pedra há cerca de 10 mil anos.
 
14.jan.2016 - O maior fóssil intacto da baleia Basulosaurus isis é exposto no Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito. O governo inaugurou o primeiro museu de fósseis no Oriente Médio no local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco, na tentativa de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos recentes ataques de radicais no país.
 
14.jan.2016 - Este fóssil gigante é de uma baleia e está exposto do lado de fora do Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito. O espaço foi inaugurado na quinta-feira (14) em um local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco, na tentativa de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos recentes ataques de radicais no país.
 
14.jan.2016 - Este fóssil gigante é de uma baleia e está exposto do lado de fora do Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito. O espaço foi inaugurado na quinta-feira (14) em um local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco, na tentativa de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos recentes ataques de radicais no país.
 
14.jan.2016 - O Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan tem um formato interessante e fica no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito, local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco. Nele, estão expostos fósseis gigantes de baleias e outros animais pré-históricos. É uma tentativa do governo egípcio de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos conflitos armados ocorridos no país.
 
14.jan.2016 - Visitante observa fóssil gigante de uma baleia Basilosaurus isis exposta no Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, durante a sua inauguração, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito, local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco. O animal foi um cetáceo pré-histórico que viveu entre 34 e 39 milhões de anos atrás, considerado antigo parente dos golfinhos e baleias atuais.
 
14.jan.2016 - Este fóssil gigante é de uma baleia e está exposto do lado de fora do Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito. O espaço foi inaugurado na quinta-feira (14) em um local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco, na tentativa de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos recentes ataques de radicais no país.
 
14.jan.2016 - O maior fóssil intacto da baleia Basilosaurus isis é exposto no Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito. O animal foi um cetáceo pré-histórico que viveu entre 34 e 39 milhões de anos atrás, considerado antigo parente dos golfinhos e baleias atuais. O governo inaugurou o primeiro museu de fósseis no Oriente Médio no local considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco, na tentativa de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos recentes ataques de radicais no país..
 
14.jan.2016 - Com a estratégia de atrair turistas, afugentados pelos recentes conflitos armados no Egito, nada mais lógico que enviar soldados do Exército para fazer a segurança durante a inauguração do Museu de Fósseis e Mudanças Climáticas Wati El Hitan, no oásis de Fayoum, no Egito. O local é considerado Patrimônio da Humanidade pela Unesco. O museu é o primeiro a reunir fósseis no Oriente Médio.
 
13.JAN.2016 - Um estudo feito por pesquisadores brasileiros com pontas de projéteis em pedra lascada sugere que o povoamento da América do Sul pode ser mais antigo do que se imagina. Antes se acreditava que a cultura Clovis, do Novo México (EUA), fosse a mais antiga das Américas, pois foram encontradas de pedra de 13,5 mil anos. No entanto, pontas achadas na Argentina têm datações que variam entre 12,9 mil e 12,3 mil. Já as de Monte Verde (Chile), datam também de 13,5 mil anos, enquanto o sítio arqueológico onde foram encontradas era ocupado há pelo menos 18 mil anos. As 32 pontas de projéteis encontradas no Brasil, e reunidas no estudo, não possuem data definida mas foram encontradas em sítios arqueológicos que datam, o mais antigo, de 32 mil anosImagem: Mercedes Okumura/Agência Fapesp/Divulgação.

12.jan.2016 - Imagem cedida pelo Departamento de Arqueologia da Universidade de Cambridge mostra vestígios de edifícios circulares construídos durante a Idade do Bronze ( 3300 a.C.) encontrado na pedreira Must Farm, Whittlesey, Reino Unido no último dia 8 de janeiro. A escavação recuperou vários instrumentos e objetos pertencentes a época e permitirá um estudo mais detalhado de como era a vida naquela época. Segundo os arqueólogos, o assentamento foi destruído pelo fogo e, posteriormente coberto pelo rio, graças ao qual os objetos encontrados nos sedimentos de turfa do rio Nene foram preservados em condições extraordinárias.

14.dez.2015 - O Museu Arqueológico de Madri, na Espanha, recebe a múmia guanche de Barranco de Herques, exemplo de restos mumificados das culturas pré-hispânicas das Ilhas Canárias com os quais o museu abre um espaço temático.
 
30.nov.2015 - Uma das ferramentas feitas a partir de pedra encontradas no sítio arqueológico de Monte Verde, no Chile. Novas descobertas apontam que a América do Sul contou com humanos há até 18.000 anos, contrariando teoria de que os primeiros habitantes não chegaram antes de 13.000 anos atrás. Na foto, pedra feita há entre 15.000 e 16.000 anos, encontrada no Chile.  
 
17.nov.2015 - Um esqueleto que data de quase 10 mil anos foi encontrado no abrigo Kotias Klde, no oeste da Geórgia. O DNA extraído do crânio e de um dente molar da ossada está ajudando a desvendar a ascendência multifacetada dos europeus modernos. Segundo cientistas da Universidade de Cambrigde, no Reino Unido, que sequenciaram o genoma, essa linhagem teria surgido da mistura das populações de caçadores-coletores, que resistiram à era glacial, com outras populações ancestrais.
 
11.nov.2015 - Foto feita do alto mostra monumento pré-histórico feito em pedra conhecido como Rujm el-Hiri, que em árabe quer dizer "pilha de pedras do gato selvagem", enquanto um piloto de parapente sobrevoa o lugar, em foto feita em 24 de julho de 2014. Por séculos, o monumento passou desapercebido mesmo estando em uma área descampada nas Colinas de Golã, em Israel. Só depois que Israel capturou o território da Síria em 1967, arqueólogos que estudavam a região descobriram o monumento, que seria contemporâneo de Stonehenge, na Inglaterra, sendo é uma das mais antigas e mais misteriosas estruturas do Oriente Médio.
 
5.nov.2015 - Esqueletos sepultados no século 19 são descobertos no subsolo de uma rua no coração do campus da New York University, em NY, durante as obras para trocar a tubulação de água principal da via. Acredita-se que as criptas sejam parte do cemitério de uma Igreja Presbiteriana. Há corpos de entre nove e 12 pessoas e alguns caixões de madeira. No fim do século 17, a região era palco de execuções públicas. Arqueólogos trabalharão na tentativa de identificar os corpos, se possível.
 
ANCESTRAL CHINÊS - O "Homo sapiens" chegou ao que hoje é a China entre 80 mil e 120 mil anos atrás. A descoberta mostra que nosso ancestral saiu do continente africano cerca de 70.000 anos antes do que se pensava. A pesquisa, publicada na revista Nature, foi possível após os pesquisadores encontrarem dentes humanos em uma caverna na província chinesa de Hunan. As descobertas colocam ainda em evidência que os primeiros humanos tal e como conhecemos - que supostamente emergiram na África Oriental há 200.000 anos - foram chineses antes de serem europeus.
 
Ao menos três esqueletos de dinossauros ainda no ovo ou pouco após a eclosão no momento da morte foram descobertos na região chamada "tumba do dragão" no deserto de Gobi na Mongólia - anunciaram nesta quarta-feira (14) os cientistas belgas.
 
RATO ANCESTRAL - RATO ANCESTRAL - A descoberta de um fóssil de 125 milhões de anos pode ajudar os cientistas a entender a evolução das espinhos e dos pelos entre mamíferos. O fóssil da espécie "Spinolestes xenarthrosus", semelhante a um rato, foi encontrado em Cuenca, na Espanha. Este fóssil estava muito bem preservado, com pelos (e seus folículos preservados), além de órgãos e tinha até uma infecção por fungos. Antes dele, o animal com pelos e espinhos mais preservados que se tinha notícia tinha cerca de 60 milhões de anos a menos que este. Acredita-se que os "Spinolestes xenarthrosus" mediam cerca de 24 centímetros e possuíam um peso estimado entre 50 e 70 gramas. Os resultados foram obtidos por pesquisadores da Universidade Autônoma de Madri e da Universidade de Chicago e serão publicados na revista Nature nesta quinta-feira (15).
 
29.set.2015 - PRÉ-HISTÓRIA - Pelo fossilizado de morcego conhecido como Palaeochiropteryx hassianycteris encontrado em Messel, na Alemanha. A pigmentação, baseada em microscópicas estruturas, permite saber a cor da espécie de 49 milhões de anos: marrom avermelhada.
 
29.set.2015 - Tomografia de rosto de múmia de Pompeia, atingida pela erupção do Vesúvio, em 79 d.C. Dentes eram perfeitos, consequência de alimentação saudável das vítimasImagem: Superintendência Arqueológica de Pompeia/EFE.



29.set.2015 - Tomografia axial computadorizada de múmia de Pompeia, na Itália. Um projeto investiga os hábitos e as classes sociais das vítimas da erupção do Vesúvio, no ano 79 d.C..

NOVA ESPÉCIE - Cientistas do Museu Universidade do Alasca do Norte descobriram uma nova espécie de dinossauro, a "Ugrunaaluk kuukpikensis", que habitou a encosta norte da região, no período cretáceo. A espécie se alimentava de plantas espessas e, por isso, possuía uma arcada dentária forte. O Ugrunaaluk chegava a medir até nove metros de comprimento e é do tipo hadrossauro, ou seja, possui uma espécie de "bico de pato". Esses animais viviam na escuridão por meses e provavelmente enfrentavam a neve. Outras duas espécies já foram identificadas na região, uma que se alimentava de plantas e a outra era carnívora. O estudo foi publicado nesta terça-feira (22) no periódico Acta Palaeontologica Polonica.

22.set.2015 - Esqueletos de soldados mortos na batalha de Lutzen (1632), são fotografados em uma vala comum no museu de Halle/ Saale, na Alemanha. Restos mortais de 47 soldados encontrados em uma vala comum serão exibido em uma exposição chamada "Uma busca arqueológica", que estará aberta ao público de 6 de novembro de 2015 a 22 de maio de 2016. A batalha de Lutzen aconteceu durante a Guerra dos Trinta Anos: conflito entre católicos e protestantes marcou Europa de 1618 a 1648.

17.set.2015 - 17.set.2015 - Esqueletos de soldados do grande exército de Napoleão são descobertos por arqueólogos em um canteiro de obras em Frankfurt, na Alemanha. Os restos mortais fazem parte da tropa de 200 mil soldados do Exército napoleônico mortos em 1813, durante o caminho de volta à Europa, após serem derrotados na Rússia.

10.set.2015 - Fragmentos de ossos são organizados com partes do esqueleto do 'Homo Naledi', a espécie recém-descoberta classificada dentro do gênero Homo, ao qual pertence o homem moderno. Juntos, os fragmentos mostram uma surpreendente mistura de características primitivas e semelhantes a da raça humana.

10.set.2015 - Cientista mostra a reconstrução da face do Homo Naledi durante o anúncio da descoberta em Magaliesburg, na África do Sul. Um conjunto de ossos mostrou que o novo membro da árvore genealógica humana apresenta uma surpreendente mistura de características humanas e primitivas.

10.set.2015 - O vice-presidente da África do Sul, Cyril Ramaphosa, segura uma réplica do crânio da espécie Homo Naledi, recém-descoberta no país. Fósseis do acestral humano foram encontrados em uma caverna profunda de difícil acesso, perto de Johannesburgo, na área arqueológica conhecida como "Berço da Humanidade", que é considerada patrimônio mundial pela Unesco.

10.set.2015 - Arcada dentária do Homo Naledi foi encontrada em caverna profunda de difícil acesso, perto de Johannesburgo (África do Sul), na área arqueológica conhecida como "Berço da Humanidade", que é considerada patrimônio mundial pela Unesco.

10.set.2015 - Fragmentos de ossos são organizados com partes do esqueleto do Homo Naledi, a espécie recém-descoberta classificada dentro do gênero Homo, ao qual pertence o homem moderno. Juntos, os fragmentos mostram uma surpreendente mistura de características primitivas e semelhantes a da raça humana.

10.set.2015 - Uma antiga espécie do gênero humano desconhecida até agora foi descoberta em uma caverna da África do Sul, onde foram exumados os ossos de 15 hominídeos, anunciou nesta quinta-feira uma equipe internacional de cientistas. A nova espécia foi batizada de 'Homo Naledi' e classificada dentro do gênero Homo, ao qual pertence o homem moderno.

17.ago.2015 - FLOR ANCESTRAL - Paleobotânicos da Universidade de Indiana, nos Estados Unidos, juntamente com colegas europeus, identificaram uma planta de água doce de 125 milhões de anos, uma das primeiras angiospermas com flores encontradas no planeta Terra. A imagem foi publicada na segunda-feira (17) no periódico da Academia de Ciências dos Estados Unidos (PNAS). "Isso de 'primeira flor' é tecnicamente um mito, como o 'primeiro humano'", disse o paleobotânico David Dilcher, principal autor do estudo. "Mas com base nesta nova análise, sabemos que a Montsechia é contemporânea, inclusive mais antiga, do que a Archaefructus (sinensis)", uma planta aquática similar, encontrada na China.

6.ago.2015 - O mais completo exemplar de um esqueleto de tatu-­gigante foi encontrado numa caverna na região de Iramaia, na Chapada Diamantina (BA), durante expedição realizada por espeleólogos e pesquisadores da UFSCar (Universidade Federal de São Carlos).O bicho de 220 kg, que pertencia à espécie Holmesina major, era herbívoro e preferia uma dieta de grama, diferentemente dos insetos e outros pequenos animais consumidos por seus parentes de hoje.
 
3.ago.2015 - O mais longo fêmur de um dinossauro foi encontrado no sítio arqueológico de Angeac-Charente, no sudoeste da França. O osso pertence à infraordem dos saurópodes, conhecido pelo corpo enorme, pescoço muito comprido e cabeça muito pequena. O sítio arqueológico francês é um dos mais importantes pela enorme quantidade de fósseis de dinossauros presentes.
 
Mandíbula e maxilar de Filipe 2° da Macedônia.
 
Veja mais: http://noticias.uol.com.br/ciencia/album/2013/10/31/veja-descobertas-arqueologicas.htm?fotoNavId=prf1116bc9342e81823b73959768f91e4b20161004#fotoNavId=pr344d34c7a021881709fc823ae21cf20150702
 
 


 
 
 
 
 
 
 




 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 




Hominin skull discovery fuels debate about early human evolution

The face of Dmanisi Skull 5.
Credit: 
Courtesy of Guram Bumbiashvili, Georgian National Museum
The Dmanisi Skull 5 early Homo cranium and herbivore fossil remains in situ at the discovery site.
Credit: Courtesy of Georgian National Museum
Artist's reconstruction of the original Homo erectus owner of Dmanisi Skull' 5.
Credit: 
Courtesy of J.H. Matternes
The Dmanisi site (in the upper right of the photograph), lies beneath a small medieval town about 85 kilometers from Georgia's capital Tbilisi. The site sits on top of a lava flow and covers some 50,000 square meters.
Credit: Courtesy of Fernando Javier Urquijo
Five different hominid skulls have been found at Dmanisi so far, all exhibiting slightly different traits. The newest one, Skull 5 on the far right, is believed to be Homo erectus. The question is whether all five are Homo erectus or are different species.

Credit: Courtesy of M. Ponce de León and Ch. Zollikofer, University of Zurich, Switzerland
Hailed as a find for the ages, a rare skull of a 1.8-million-year-old human relative could provide answers to longstanding questions about the lineage of our species. It also fuels debate over what differentiates one hominin species from another, and could mean that Homo habilis, Homo rudolfensis and other early bipedal hominins may all be members of Homo erectus, rather than distinct species.

A jawbone found at an archaeological site in Dmanisi, Georgia, in 2000 was matched to a skull uncovered in 2005 just 2 meters away. Together, they represent the most completely preserved adult skull yet discovered from that period, according to paleoarchaeologist David Lordkipanidze of the Georgian National Museum, who reported the discovery with his colleagues this week in Science.
What makes the skull most interesting to the team is the difference in its size and shape compared to four other skulls found thus far at the site, which is about 85 kilometers southwest of Georgia’s capital, Tbilisi. Some of the skulls — two from adolescents and a third from an elderly individual — have larger or rounder braincases, or more pronounced eyebrow ridges.

The authors describe two possibilities to explain the dimensional variation between the skulls, which all date to the same time period. Either they belong to separate species and ended up in the same place at the same time, or they are members of the same species exhibiting differences between individuals.

Because the five individuals lived in the same community, and because the variability in measurements of their skull dimensions falls within the range seen in other primates, the researchers concluded that they belong to the same species, Homo erectus.
“The five Dmanisi individuals are no more different from each other than five [modern] humans or chimpanzees,” said co-author Christoph Zollikofer, a paleoanthropologist at the Anthropological Institute and Museum of the University of Zurich, at a press conference this week. Homo erectus lived in Africa and spread across the world between 1.8 million and 143,000 years ago.
Their conclusion could push other species, thought to be distinct members of the Homo lineage, out of the accepted story of human evolution, the authors said. Homo habilis and Homo rudolfensis are early hominins that lived in Africa at about the same time as the Dmanisi examples. Both species are known by only a few fossils and their skulls are more ape-like than human, two reasons their classification has been complicated.

Many scientists have praised the find, but some have reservations about the report’s conclusions. “It should be said before anything else that it’s an absolutely fabulous specimen. There’s nothing as well-preserved for that time period,” Fred Spoor, a paleontologist at University College London who helped find and describe Homo rudolfensis and habilis and wasn’t involved in the new research, told EARTH. Nonetheless, he says he isn’t convinced that the discovery spells the end for the other hominin species.

Spoor points to specific features of Skull 5, as the new example is known. “The overall shape of the braincase is something that only Homo erectus has, and you can’t find it in Homo habilis or rudolfensis,” he says. Instead, “what you have in my view is a fascinating skull with a number of primitive features combined with a number of very typical erectus features,” he says. “The braincase takes on Homo erectus features whereas the face is still sort of ancestral.”
In response, Zollikofer returns to the group’s argument in favor of individual differences within species. He told EARTH that the only example of a Homo rudolfensis skull has been reconstructed from fragments, so there are questions about it. In addition, he says, “it is straightforward to find two modern human braincases that differ more in shape than those of habilis, erectus or rudolfensis.”
Among the details the team provided about the skull is that its braincase volume — 546 milliliters — is about a third the volume of an average modern human. Skull 5’s original owner also suffered an injury to its right cheekbone, which broke and healed during its lifetime.

Based on how and where the five Dmanisi skulls have been found, archaeologists think that carnivores dragged the corpses into their dens, all likely within a few hundred years of each other. Sabre-toothed tigers and giant cheetah bones have also been found at the dig. “It seems that they were fighting for the carcasses and unfortunately for the hominins, but fortunately for us, they were not always successful” in fending off predators, Zollikofer said at the press conference.
The Dmanisi site, which lies beneath a small medieval town, sits on top of a lava flow and covers some 50,000 square meters, according to the group. Archaeologists suggest that early humans lived by a river there, and they have found stone tools likely used for butchering animals and other tasks.

Homo floresiensis


Image of female hobbit reconstruction based on LB-1 by John Gurche
Homo floresiensis
Nickname: the Hobbit
Where Lived: Asia (Indonesia)
When Lived: About 100,000 – 50,000 years ago
Homo floresiensis lived about 95,000 – 17,000 years ago.
Remains of one of the most recently discovered early human species, Homo floresiensis (nicknamed ‘Hobbit’), have so far only been found on the Island of Flores, Indonesia. The fossils of H. floresiensis date to between about 100,000 and 60,000 years ago, and stone tools made by this species date to between about 190,000 and 50,000 years old. H. floresiensis individuals stood approximately 3 feet 6 inches tall, had tiny brains, large teeth for their small size, shrugged-forward shoulders, no chins, receding foreheads, and relatively large feet due to their short legs. Despite their small body and brain size, H. floresiensis made and used stone tools, hunted small elephants and large rodents, coped with predators such as giant Komodo dragons, and may have used fire. 

The diminutive stature and small brain of H. floresiensis may have resulted from island dwarfism—an evolutionary process that results from long-term isolation on a small island with limited food resources and a lack of predators. Pygmy elephants on Flores, now extinct, showed the same adaptation. The smallest known species of Homo and Stegodon elephant are both found on the island of Flores, Indonesia.  However, some scientists are now considering the possibility that the ancestors of H. floresiensis may have been small when they first reached Flores.

One of our own scientists, Dr. Matt Tocheri, does research on this enigmatic early human species; read more about this work, and watch a video about it on this page.

Year of Discovery: 2003
History of Discovery:  A joint Indonesian-Australian research team found LB-1—a nearly complete female skeleton of a tiny human that lived about 80,000 years ago—in Liang Bua cave on the island of Flores, Indonesia. The skeleton’s unique traits such as its small body and brain size led scientists to assign the skeleton to a new species, Homo floresiensis, named after the island on which it was discovered.
Since the initial find, bones and teeth representing as many as 12 H. floresiensis individuals have been recovered at Liang Bua—the only site where H. floresiensis has been found so far. The bulk of the finds related to H. floresiensis date between 100,000 and 60,000 years ago, with stone tools made by this species dating between 190,00 and 50,000 years ago.

Height: 106 cm (3 ft 6 in) - estimate from a female skeleton
 
Weight: 30 kg (66 lbs) - estimate from a female skeleton
 
We don’t know everything about our early ancestors—but we keep learning more! Paleoanthropologists are constantly in the field, excavating new areas with groundbreaking technology, and continually filling in some of the gaps about our understanding of human evolution.
Below are some of the still unanswered questions about Homo floresiensis that may be answered with future discoveries: 
  1. Which hominin species made the 1 million year old stone tools found on Flores?
  2. How did these early humans manage to get to the island of Flores?
  3. Did H. floresiensis have language, make art, and have other forms of cultural expression?
  4. Did H. floresiensis and our species, H. sapiens, ever come into contact with one another?
  5. Was a volcanic eruption on Flores the reason H. floresiensis went extinct?
  6. How similar is the DNA of H. floresiensis to the DNA of other human species? So far, no DNA has been retrieved from the bones of a H. floresiensis individual.
How They Survived:  Stone tools found on the island of Flores show that early humans arrived there at least 1 million years ago, but it’s not known how early humans got there as the nearest island is 9 km (6 mi) away across treacherous seas. Paleoanthropologists found many stone tools associated with H. floresiensis, and these tools are broadly similar to those found earlier on Flores and throughout the human evolutionary career (i.e., Lower Paleolithic tools in Asia or Oldowan tools in Africa).  There is also evidence that H. floresiensis selectively hunted Stegodon (an extinct type of elephant) as hundreds of Stegodon bone fragments are found within H. floresiensis occupation layers and some of these Stegodon bones show butchery marks.

Evolutionary Tree Information:  Although there has been considerable scientific debate over whether LB-1 (the holotype of Homo floresiensis) may represent a modern human with a disease or growth disorder, most scientists now recognize H. floresiensis as a valid taxon and a human species distinct from Homo sapiens (modern humans). Scientists are now trying to figure out exactly how H. floresiensis is related to other species in the genus Homo. For example, did H. floresiensis evolve from an earlier population of H. erectus, or did it evolve from a smaller species, such as the early humans found in Dmanisi (Republic of Georgia), or perhaps another early species of the genus Homo?

LB-1

Image of LB1 skeleton, Flores, Indonesia
This female’s head, like the rest of her body, was unusually small. Her brain was about a third the size of ours, but her species made and used stone tools, and hunted a variety of animals. The small body size of Homo floresiensis may have helped the species survive on an island with limited resources.
Read more about this fossil.

LB-1

Image of LB-1, Flores Indonesia; Skull, 3/4 view
This female’s head, like the rest of her body, was unusually small. Her brain was about a third the size of ours, but her species made and used stone tools, and hunted a variety of animals. The small body size of Homo floresiensis may have helped the species survive on an island with limited resources.
Read more about this fossil.

Redefining homo: Does our family tree need more branches?

  The hominin family tree is frequently revised, but researchers disagree about where many fossils should be placed on the tree. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI. The hominin family tree is frequently revised, but researchers disagree about where many fossils should be placed on the tree. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI.
As the sole surviving species of the genus Homo, we Homo sapiens are one of the most taxonomically lonely species living on Earth today. But dig back a few thousand years or more and we find ourselves with plenty of company: Many now-extinct species shared the genus Homo, ranging from the robust Homo neanderthalensis, to the hobbit-like Homo floresiensis to the more primitive Homo habilis and Homo erectus. But do all these species, with their wide diversity of physical and cultural traits, actually belong in the same genus?

Traditionally, hominin fossils have been classified into either the genus Homo or Australopithecus, with Homo dating back to about 2.8 million years and the oldest Australopiths dating back to about 4 million years ago. But some anthropologists think we need more options. “Right now, we are stuck in a false dichotomy, where if it isn’t an Australopith, it must be Homo and if it isn’t Homo, it must be an Australopith,” says Ian Tattersall, a paleoanthropologist at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City. “We obviously need more genera if our classification of hominins is to meaningfully reflect the diversity within our family.”

But reparsing the hominin family tree is easier said than done. “This problem is just as much philosophical as taxonomical,” Tattersall says. “We’re wrestling with nothing less than human exceptionalism” — the idea that humans are so distinct from other organisms that the rules of taxonomy don’t apply to us, a problem that has plagued paleoanthropology from its earliest discoveries. “Homo has become a wastebasket of names with very little meaning,” Tattersall says. “And yet, we’re so emotionally attached to those names that even people who think they should be changed are unable to agree on how to go about it.” Nonetheless, some are trying.

What’s in a Name?

In the mid-1700s, Swedish botanist Carl Linnaeus proposed a binomial naming system to classify organisms according to relatedness and shared characteristics. This organizational system evolved into the familiar ranks of kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus and species.
A species is loosely defined as a population of organisms that can successfully breed. But things get a little more contrived at the genus level, which is less rooted in biology and more in the scientific drive for organization. “Species have a reasonably objective biological reality that is grounded in the dynamic that exists among their members,” Tattersall wrote in the journal Inference in February 2016. “Genera, on the other hand, are purely historical constructs,” he wrote.

“A genus is like a make of car,” says Bernard Wood, a paleoanthropologist at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. All Toyotas are more closely related to each other than to any other make of car and they’re all derived from the original Toyota, which was made in the 1930s, he adds. A grouping made up of “all the four-wheel-drive cars made by Toyota would make a sensible genus,” Wood says. “But a grouping of four-wheel-drive cars made by different companies would not qualify, even if they look alike and drive alike, since they don’t share a common ancestor.”
Three-dimensional skull casts of early hominins (left to right): Australopithecus africanus, 2.5 million years old from Sterkfontein in South Africa; Homo rudolfensis, 1.9 million years old from Koobi Fora, Kenya; Homo erectus, 1 million years old from Java, Indonesia; Homo heidelbergensis, 350,000 years old from Thessalonika, Greece; and Homo sapiens, 4,800 years old from Fish Hoek, South Africa. Credit: Smithsonian Institution. Three-dimensional skull casts of early hominins (left to right): Australopithecus africanus, 2.5 million years old from Sterkfontein in South Africa; Homo rudolfensis, 1.9 million years old from Koobi Fora, Kenya; Homo erectus, 1 million years old from Java, Indonesia; Homo heidelbergensis, 350,000 years old from Thessalonika, Greece; and Homo sapiens, 4,800 years old from Fish Hoek, South Africa. Credit: Smithsonian Institution.
 
Genera are not as easy to define when it comes to living organisms, however, especially those as complicated and poorly represented in the fossil record as early hominins. Prior to the mid-1900s, paleoanthropologists used taxonomic names to refer to particular fossil specimens, and by the mid-20th century they had racked up more than a dozen different genera, most of which were actually the same species: Homo neanderthalensis. “The first paleontologists were experts in anatomy, not taxonomy,” Tattersall says. “They were tuned in to these minor [anatomical] differences between specimens and named them not only as separate species, but entirely different genera.”
In 1963, taxonomist and ornithologist Ernst Mayr tried to set everybody straight by dragging the field in the opposite direction. “Mayr was the original lumper,” says Jeff Schwartz, a physical anthropologist at the University of Pittsburgh. Mayr was known as the leading architect of the new evolutionary synthesis, which held that evolution was a gradual process where species gave rise to the next through natural selection in a neatly linear fashion.

Despite never having seen a hominin fossil, Mayr declared there was only one genus in the hominin family — Homo — and that there were only three species, each giving way to the next in an orderly fashion: Homo transvaalensis (roughly equivalent to what we call Australopiths today) gave rise to Homo erectus, which paved the way for Homo sapiens to populate the planet.
“Mayr grouped members simply on the basis of bipedalism: everything bipedal was automatically Homo. He never looked at fossils and never looked at the literature,” Schwartz says. “It’s mind-boggling that the field of paleoanthropology is still being influenced to this day by a nonpaleoanthropologist. We’ve effectively been mired in Mayr’s misunderstanding since 1963.”

How Do You Define Homo?

  When Carl Linnaeaus proposed a binomial naming system, he gave each plant and animal at least one qualifying characteristic that set them apart, but for humans, he wrote “Know thyself.” And to this day, “Homo sapiens” has not been properly defined, researchers say. In 1769, anatomist Johann Friedrich Blumenbach compiled a list including a chin, small jaws, small canines abutting small incisors, a large braincase balanced atop a vertical vertebral column, erect posture, bipedalism, a bowl-shaped pelvic girdl When Carl Linnaeaus proposed a binomial naming system, he gave each plant and animal at least one qualifying characteristic that set them apart, but for humans, he wrote “Know thyself.” And to this day, “Homo sapiens” has not been properly defined, researchers say. In 1769, anatomist Johann Friedrich Blumenbach compiled a list including a chin, small jaws, small canines abutting small incisors, a large braincase balanced atop a vertical vertebral column, erect posture, bipedalism, a bowl-shaped pelvic girdle, buttocks and a long thumb. In 1963, Ernst Mayr lumped all hominins into the same genus: Homo. More recently, paleoanthropologists tend to use one or more of four criteria to include hominins as members of Homo, as shown above. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI.
When Linnaeus was laying out his case for a binomial naming system, he bestowed Latin genus and species names on a number of plants and animals, including humans. For each plant and animal, he gave at least one qualifying characteristic that set them apart, but for humans, he simply wrote, “Nosce te ipsum,” or “Know thyself.”

“To this day, Homo sapiens have not been properly defined,” Tattersall says, despite being the type fossil for Homo. Attempts to do so usually result in a grab bag of features that distinguish us from other mammals. In 1795, anatomist Johann Friedrich Blumenbach compiled a list including a chin, small jaws, small canines abutting small incisors, a large braincase balanced atop a vertical vertebral column, erect posture, bipedalism, a bowl-shaped pelvic girdle, buttocks and a long thumb.
Without a formal definition for even Homo sapiens, determining which fossils should fit into the genus is tricky, Wood says. “We’re looking for fossil species that are not identical to modern humans but are not so different from modern humans that you would want to put them in a different adaptive group.” Adaptive groups are made up of related organisms that share similar adaptations and lifestyles — such as marine mammals. “Arguments arise when you talk about how far away from modern humans you can get in terms of morphology while still maintaining an argument of adaptive coherence,” he says.

Paleoanthropologists have traditionally used one or more of four criteria to include hominins as members of Homo: an adult brain size of more than 600 cubic centimeters; limb, hand and foot proportions similar to modern humans; the ability to communicate through language; and the ability to manufacture stone tools. “However, none of these criteria are very satisfactory,” Tattersall says, especially since they have each been stretched and distorted repeatedly over the years to accommodate newly discovered fossils.

Brain size was the original preferred defining feature for Homo, says paleoanthropologist Rick Potts, director of the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program at the National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C. “Brain size was fairly easy to measure, even given only fragments of the skull, and it presented a nice, linear trend: As Homo got more sophisticated, brain size got bigger.” But while brain size is useful in defining the later members of Homo, drawing the line between Australopiths and the earliest members of Homo is difficult. “Early members of the genus Homo had fairly small brains that overlapped with the brain size of Australopithecus,” Potts says. “If you’re going to define the genus Homo at its branching point from Australopiths, brain size is not the best way to do it.”
  One of the traditional ways to distinguish Homo from other genuses is by brain size. Homo has an adult brain size of more than 600 cubic centimeters. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI, after Shultz and Mason, 2013. One of the traditional ways to distinguish Homo from other genuses is by brain size. Homo has an adult brain size of more than 600 cubic centimeters. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI, after Shultz and Mason, 2013.
 
Proportions of the limbs, hands and feet offer more clear-cut measurements to distinguish early Homo from Australopiths, which were smaller in stature and had limbs, hands and feet that were still geared toward an arboreal lifestyle in the trees. “For Australopiths, becoming bipedal was a real defining feature,” says Fred Spoor, a paleoanthropologist at the University College London in England. But limb proportions are quite similar between species of Homo, making it difficult to differentiate species based on their proportions. “Once we start seeing the modern body plan in early Homo, it’s difficult to draw the line between one species and another based simply on the limb proportions.”
Spoken language is another criterion that could be used to distinguish Homo, but while endocranial casts can offer some clues for the development of the language centers of the brain, definitive physical evidence for the origin of complex spoken language is thin. “All we can do is to look at the archaeological record and make inferences about whether speech would have been necessary for their level of culture and society,” Wood says. “That’s a long chain of inference so I’m reluctant to use complex spoken language as a criterion for Homo.”
The ability to manufacture stone tools is a common way to differentiate Homo from other hominins. These handaxes are from early hominins. Left to right: Africa (1.6 million years old), Asia (1.1 million years old), and Europe (250,000 years old). Credit: Chip Clark, Smithsonian Institution. The ability to manufacture stone tools is a common way to differentiate Homo from other hominins. These handaxes are from early hominins. Left to right: Africa (1.6 million years old), Asia (1.1 million years old), and Europe (250,000 years old). Credit: Chip Clark, Smithsonian Institution.
 
In the 1960s, the idea of defining Homo according to tool use was very much in vogue. “‘Man the toolmaker’ was an interesting notion at the time, but like a lot of interesting notions, it’s a hypothesis that has probably been refuted,” Wood says. “The tool use criterion is not very helpful because it’s quite likely that Australopithecus also used tools. Even chimps use tools, though they are less adept at actually making tools, but it seems like the cognitive basis for tool use was present in the common ancestor of chimps and modern humans.”

Over the years, people have proposed alternative criteria for defining Homo, some more helpful than others. Tooth size is fairly useful, especially since teeth are some of the most commonly preserved parts of the skeleton. “Early hominins had much larger teeth than we do relative to our body size,” Wood says. Paranthropus, for example, is a genus of early hominins distinguished by their significantly larger teeth — so large the first specimen of Paranthropus boisei, discovered in 1959, was nicknamed “Nutcracker Man.” As early hominins developed stone tools, they were able to process foods outside the mouth and the selection for large teeth diminished.

Others have proposed using developmental growth as a criterion, as humans and apes have very different growth patterns. “Modern humans have a childhood and a prolonged growth period, but if you look at chimps, they go from being infants to young adults in a number of weeks,” Wood says.
Perhaps the most radical idea for grouping species into genera is on the basis of time, with lines drawn between species based on when they evolved and how long they survived. “It’s a perfectly logical solution to the problem,” says Mark Collard, an anthropologist at Simon Fraser University in Burnaby, British Columbia. “But one of the consequences is that we end up with modern chimps and gorillas being classified as Homo. I don’t think many people in the field feel comfortable with that, though I’m not sure they’re willing or able to articulate why.”

Not all paleoanthropologists agree that the genus Homo needs to be changed or redefined. Some see the creation of more genera as merely overcomplicating an arbitrary naming system. “When we talk about how species should be in a genus or a family, it’s kind of like asking, ‘How high is up?’” says Brian Villmoare, a paleoanthropologist at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. “Nature does its thing. It finds new niches and lineages split. We’ve invented this system of taxonomy for organizational purposes and it’s essentially arbitrary,” Villmoare says. Creating new genera doesn’t add new information; rather, it just adds demarcations “somewhere on a continuum,” he says. “I don’t see the value in that.”

Rebranding Homo

Comparison of skull features of replicas of Homo habilis (1.8 million years old, from Koobi Fora, Kenya), Homo erectus (1.8 million years old, from Dmanisi, Georgia), Homo floresiensis (from Liang Bua, Flores, Indonesia, perhaps 20,000 years old) and Homo naledi (age unknown, from South Africa). Actual fragments of Homo naledi material were overlaid on a virtual reconstruction. Credit: Chris Stringer, eLIFE, September 2015, CC BY 4.0. Comparison of skull features of replicas of Homo habilis (1.8 million years old, from Koobi Fora, Kenya), Homo erectus (1.8 million years old, from Dmanisi, Georgia), Homo floresiensis (from Liang Bua, Flores, Indonesia, perhaps 20,000 years old) and Homo naledi (age unknown, from South Africa). Actual fragments of Homo naledi material were overlaid on a virtual reconstruction. Credit: Chris Stringer, eLIFE, September 2015, CC BY 4.0.
 
If scientists were going to rebrand Homo, who would be “in” and who would be “out”? “I would allow Homo erectus in, but I would draw the line at Homo habilis,” Wood says. Homo habilis is the original problem child of the paleoanthropological community. Described in 1964 by Louis Leakey and colleagues, the team named their find the “handy man” in reference to a collection of stone tools found in association with the fossils, which dated to about 1.75 million years ago. At the time, the “man the toolmaker” hypothesis was in vogue, with many paleoanthropologists enthralled with the idea that tool use should be the defining feature of the genus Homo.
  Homo sapiens skull features, for comparison. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI; skull: ©iStockphoto.com/Chinnasorn Pangcharoen. Homo sapiens skull features, for comparison. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI; skull: ©iStockphoto.com/Chinnasorn Pangcharoen.
But Homo habilis is more similar in size and body type to Australopithecus. The original fossil described by Leakey had a brain slightly bigger than the average Australopith, but the brains of subsequent specimens have been smaller, between 340 and 500 cubic centimeters. “If you include Homo habilis in Homo, you end up including a species that had limb proportions that are closer to Australopithecus, as well as dentition and a jaw whose scaling in relation to body mass is closer to Australopithecus and a brain size closer to Australopithecus,” Wood says. “A good place to draw the line” is between Australopiths and Homo, he says, adding that Homo rudolfensis, a species known from a handful of fossils found in Kenya, should also be left out of genus Homo.

However, just because Homo habilis does not belong in Homo doesn’t mean it’s an Australopith, Tattersall says. “My sense is that Homo habilis should belong to its own genus, neither Australopith nor human,” he says. “Chucking out Homo habilis makes sense because it makes Homo a morphological mess. It certainly tidies up the [Homo] genus, but stuffing it into Australopithecus just reinforces this notion that if something is not an Australopith it has to be Homo and vice versa. We need a bit more taxonomic elbow room to express the simple variety of morphology we see in the hominin fossil record.”

But this problem won’t necessarily be solved simply by coining a new name. “We need a whole new approach,” Schwartz says. “I say we start from scratch. Forget the names. Once you give something a name, you and the specimen are stuck with it. Instead of deciding how many new genera we need from the beginning, let’s start with the fossils, like you would with any other species,” Schwartz says.
A large part of the problem is that paleoanthropologists are unwilling to rebrand fossils that have already been named, Tattersall says. “Anybody who has tried to rename an existing fossil that has already been described has had a very hard time being taken seriously,” he says. The only person who has proposed a new genus lately for a fossil between Australopiths and Homo is Meave Leakey, who coined the genus Kenyanthropus for a new species she discovered in northern Kenya in 1999. “She knew it wasn’t Homo and it wasn’t an Australopith either so she came to the logical conclusion that it was something else. She got away with it because she had a new fossil, but she got dumped on considerably for it.”

Younger fossils are also trapped in a dichotomy, where if it isn’t a Neanderthal, it must be a Homo sapiens, Schwartz says. “Until about 20,000 years ago, there were Neanderthals and Homo sapiens and after then there were only Homo sapiens. But we’re finding a lot of variants in Asia, particularly China and Indonesia, and we keep classifying everything as Homo, regardless of what they look like,” he says. “A different picture is emerging of a lot more diversity in Asia in recent times than we see in Europe and Africa. And we need to stop lumping everything into Homo sapiens if we’re going to explore that diversity properly.”

The problem is highlighted by the so-called hobbits found on the Indonesian island of Flores in 2003. Standing just over a meter tall with small brains and large teeth, the hobbits defy the classical definition of Homo, and yet they have been classified as Homo floresiensis. “It’s really problematic, assigning those hobbits to Homo, when we’re talking about something that’s a meter tall, with a tiny brain by hominin standards,” Collard says. “It’s very difficult to see how that doesn’t stretch the boundaries of the genus Homo beyond what should be reasonable.”

Beating Around the Bush

Paleoanthropologists argue about whether Homo floresiensis, which stood just about a meter tall and had a much smaller brain than modern Homo sapiens, but lived very recently, should be classified as Homo. Homo floresiensis remains have been found in the Liang Bua Cave on the Indonesian island of Flores. Credit: Liang Bua Team. Paleoanthropologists argue about whether Homo floresiensis, which stood just about a meter tall and had a much smaller brain than modern Homo sapiens, but lived very recently, should be classified as Homo. Homo floresiensis remains have been found in the Liang Bua Cave on the Indonesian island of Flores. Credit: Liang Bua Team.
 
In the 18th century, when Linnaeus christened mankind as the genus Homo, people didn’t think humans had a fossil record. The history of our species was rooted in the creation story, not evolution. But nearly 300 years later, paleoanthropology is still tiptoeing around the imaginary boundary between humans and animals. “This issue plays into several big-picture, profound and philosophical questions that paleoanthropologists are often unconsciously butted up against,” Collard says. “It’s something we’ve struggled with for hundreds of years. Not just in paleoanthropology but also Western science and philosophy.”
The problem is thrown into a harsher light when comparing the classification of Homo with any other animal group, Spoor says. “For a paleontologist who studies any other animal group, there would be no hesitation to give new genus names to groups of species to comply with the rules of taxonomy. Within human evolution, these rules are constantly being violated.”

For example, before molecular testing, paleontologists could only speculate where whales and dolphins should fit into the mammalian family tree. “Then genetics came along and showed they are most closely related to hippos and even-toed ungulates, and the entire order was reclassified to reflect that radical shift with very little controversy or resistance,” Spoor says. “However, in human evolution, we’re so sensitive to creating scandal and even minor confusion that there’s great reluctance, even in papers that beautifully address this problem, to offer solutions.”

In the future, genetics may offer deeper insights into the relatedness of hominin species, but currently, the technology is limited, especially when analyzing older fossils. “A decade ago, we didn’t think there could be a Neanderthal genome project and now there is,” Potts says. “Who knows where that technology will take our genus in the future.”

Until then, paleoanthropologists will keep working on finding new fossils and placing them within the branches of the human family tree, which gets more bush-like with every new discovery. “Sometimes new fossils bring more clarity and sometimes they bring more confusion,” Wood says. “We will need to keep getting smarter about how we interpret these fossils, how we view our ancestors and how we view ourselves.”

Hominid vs. hominin

Once genetics entered the picture, the definitions of hominids and hominins changed. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI. Once genetics entered the picture, the definitions of hominids and hominins changed. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI.
 
Before genetics came along and revealed just how closely modern humans and chimpanzees are related, humans were classified in their own family, Hominidae, separate from old world monkeys, which were in the family Pongidae.

But once humans and chimps were shown to share approximately 99.4 percent of their genomes, some researchers proposed combining the families and reclassifying chimps from Pan troglodytes to Homo troglodytes. This ignited a firestorm of controversy, and the compromise was to leave chimps in the genus Pan but to lump the great apes and humans into the family Hominidae, which now includes orangutans, gorillas, chimps, bonobos and humans, collectively known as hominids. The term “hominin” now refers to all species of modern humans and early humans after their split from chimps about 14 million years ago.

The change is a prime example of how adopting new names in the field of paleoanthropology can be difficult, says Fred Spoor, a paleoanthropologist at the University College London in England. “When we start fiddling with names, everybody gets confused,” he says. “The transition over the last decade from hominids to hominins when we talk about human ancestors has been a pain. We’ve had to explain and re-explain, and people still get it wrong half the time.”

segunda-feira, 3 de outubro de 2016


An artist’s depiction of a woolly mammoth
An artist’s depiction of a woolly mammoth
Stocktrek Images Inc./Alamy Stock Photo

Should we bring extinct species back from the dead?

Earth is in the midst of its sixth mass extinction: Somewhere between 30 and 159 species disappear every day, thanks largely to humans, and more than 300 types of mammals, birds, reptiles, and amphibians have vanished since 1500. These rates do not bode well for the future of life on our planet, but what if extinction wasn’t permanent? What if we could resurrect some of the species we’ve lost?
For decades the notion of “de-extinction” hovered on the scientific fringes, but new advances in genetic engineering, especially the CRISPR-Cas9 revolution, have researchers believing that it’s time to start thinking seriously about which animals we might be able to bring back, and which ones would do the most good for the ecosystems they left behind. Indeed, earlier this month, ecologists at the University of California, Santa Barbara (UCSB), published guidelines for how to choose which species to revive if we want to do the most good for our planet's ecosystems.

The two animals at the forefront of this discussion are the woolly mammoth, a hairy, close relative of the elephant that lived in the Arctic, and the passenger pigeon, a small, gray bird with a pinkish red breast once extremely common in North America. The last mammoths died about 4000 years ago, and the passenger pigeon vanished around 1900. Research on reviving both species is well underway, and scientists close to the field think de-extinction for these animals is now a matter of “when,” not “if.”
With that prospect in mind, here’s what we know so far about de-extinction:

Why bring back extinct animals?

As cool as it might be to visit a zoo filled with woolly mammoths, saber-toothed tigers, and giant tortoises, the best reasons for bringing back extinct animals have more to do with ecology than tourism. “If this is always going to be a zoo animal, then stop,” says ecologist Ben Novak, the lead researcher on the passenger pigeon project at Revive & Restore—a foundation devoted to genetically rescuing endangered and extinct species in San Francisco, California. “The goals have to be about ecological restoration and function.”
Every animal in an ecosystem has a function: Bats eat insects, fish clean algae from coral, grazers spread nutrient-rich dung across habitats. Some functions are redundant —shared among multiple different animals—but others are fulfilled by just one or two species.
Both the passenger pigeon and woolly mammoth were functionally unique species, and when they went extinct, their habitats changed dramatically. Harvard University’s George Church, the lead researcher working to de-extinct the mammoth, says that bringing back the giants could help convert the Arctic tundra back to grasslands that existed during the last ice age. He points to research that shows that mammoths and other large herbivores trampling across the ancient Arctic ecosystems helped maintain the grasslands by knocking down trees and spreading grass seeds in the dung. When the large herbivores disappeared, the ecosystem transitioned to today’s mossy tundra and taiga that is beginning to melt and release carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Reviving the mammoth, Church says, could help slow climate change by shifting the landscape back toward the grasslands. “There’s twice as much carbon at risk in the tundra than in all the forests of the world put together.”
Likewise, the passenger pigeons, whose numbers are estimated to have reached nearly 5 billion at the start of the 19th century, played a dramatic role in shaping the forests they inhabited. Their numbers were so great and their droppings so prevalent and flammable that they destroyed trees and increased forest fires. After their extinction, these healthy natural disturbances ceased, white oaks lost their primary mode of seed dispersal (i.e., via bird droppings), and the forests have never been the same. “The passenger pigeon is a very important ecological species for the habitat that we want to restore,” Novak says.
A specimen of passenger pigeon
A specimen of passenger pigeon
The Natural History Museum/Alamy Stock Photo
How do you de-extinct an animal?
There are three main approaches to de-extinction scientists talk about. The first, called backbreeding, involves finding living species that have traits similar to the extinct species. Then scientists would selectively breed these animals to try to make a version that more closely resembles the extinct animal—a process already underway for some extinct species like aurochs. This isn’t really a true de-extinction, but it might still let us fill in missing ecological functions. In the case of mammoths, scientists might try to mate Asian elephants with more body hair than usual, for example.
A second option is cloning. Scientists would take a preserved cell from a recently extinct animal (ideally before the last of its kind died) and extract the nucleus. They would then swap this nucleus into an egg cell from the animal’s closest living relative and implant the egg into a surrogate host. (Researchers actually did this in 2007, and a common goat gave birth to an extinct species, the Pyrenean ibex. The infant lived only 7 minutes however, because of genetic problems with its lungs.) Cloning may eventually give us basically identical genetic copies of extinct species, but we’ll be restricted to animals that went extinct more recently and have well-preserved cells with intact nuclei. The mammoth and the passenger pigeon may never be cloned.

The newest option is genetic engineering. Here, researchers would line up the genome of an extinct animal with that of its closest living relative. They would then use CRISPR and other gene-editing tools to swap relevant genes from the extinct animal into the living species and implant the hybrid genome into a surrogate (or grow it in an artificial womb). This approach doesn’t produce genetically identical copies of extinct animals, but rather modern versions of an animal engineered to look and behave like its extinct relatives. This is the technology being used by the mammoth and passenger pigeon groups.

How close are we?

That depends on what you count as a true de-extinction, which is sort of a gray area. If scientists engineer an Asian elephant to have small ears, extra fur, and more body fat by swapping in mammoth DNA, is it still an Asian elephant?

“If you're willing to accept something that is an elephant that has a few mammoth genes inserted into its genome and therefore is able to make some proteins that mammoths might, we're probably closer to that,” says Beth Shapiro, author of How to Clone a Mammoth: The Science of De-Extinction and an evolutionary biologist at UC Santa Cruz specializing in ancient DNA.
The passenger pigeons project faces similar questions. Novak wants to resurrect the bird using its closest living relative, the band-tailed pigeon, but how many genes need to be swapped to constitute success is somewhat arbitrary. “The two genomes are 97% the same. That 3% has built up over many millions of years and the majority of it is noise,” he says. “So the actual differences are much likely a smaller portion—probably within the realm of several thousand mutations. What we want to find is the key 20 or 100 mutations that affect the traits that are most important.”
There’s also a divide as to what constitutes a de-extinction success for the scientists versus the public. Genetically coaxing to behave like their extinct relatives might restore the ecosystem’s lost function, Novak says. But is that good enough to count? “I don’t think anyone in the world is really going to call it de-extinction unless the bird looks right.”

Even if researchers can pinpoint and transfer those key mutations (a daunting task), DNA is only half the battle. From there it’s a matter of getting the hybrid cell to grow in a surrogate, hoping all the genes work harmoniously together, bringing the hybrid to term, and hoping it acts like the extinct species even though it was raised by a modern relative. If all that goes right, you still need the hybrids to mate and give birth to fertile offspring. “I think the hardest part is getting developmental biology to go,” says Philip Seddon, a conservation biologist at the University of Otago, Dunedin, in New Zealand and the lead author on a recent report by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) that issued guidelines for de-extinction research.
It’s a monumental task, but Novak says that if his team can secure enough funding, “there’s no reason that we can’t have the first generations of passenger pigeons by something like 2022 to 2025. Everyone running these projects would very much like to be in 10-year time frames.”
A drawing of lesser stick-nest rats
A drawing of lesser stick-nest rats
Museum Victoria/Artist: John Gould/Lithographer: H.C. Richter
How do we choose which animals to de-extinct?
In their recent publication, Douglas McCauley, an ecologist at UCSB, and his colleagues argue for three criteria to consider when choosing de-extinction candidates: Select target species with unique functions, concentrate on species that went extinct recently, and only work with species that can be restored to levels of abundance that meaningfully restore ecological function.
Although the mammoth and the passenger pigeon might pass McCauley’s first criterion, experts are skeptical about whether they’re truly the best animals to focus on. Shapiro points out that ecosystems are not static and have continued to change since these animals went extinct. “I worry about the dramatic changes to the forest in the eastern part of the North American continent,” she says. “I think there’s a lot we need to understand better about the passenger pigeon’s ecology and the effect that the passenger pigeon would have on that habitat before we can make a sufficiently educated decision.”
McCauley has similar worries: “Forests have fragmented, forests have expanded and contracted. A passenger pigeon that hits that forest again is going to be like a middle-aged guy who really wants to go back to high school and then he gets back there and he’s like, ‘Whoa I don’t fit in anymore.’”
He thinks that de-extinction efforts should instead be focused on recently extinct animals like the Christmas Island pipistrelle bat (Pipistrellus murrayi), the Réunion giant tortoise (Cylindraspis indica), and the lesser stick-nest rat (Leporillus apicalis). Although not as charismatic as a woolly mammoth, he says these creatures still have habitats to return to and would restore a unique function in their ecosystems. The lesser stick-nest rat, for instance, did what its name implies and built large stick nests in central Australia that became hubs of biodiversity.
What are the risks?
The spread of genes can be difficult to control. We probably won’t lose track of mammoths in Siberia, but what about rats? “It becomes hard to control those sorts of populations,” Seddon says. “And there are the same fears one might have about genetically modified crops—the idea that a modification may move into relatives, may jump in and out, or may not be expressed in the way that you expect.” Scientists are confident that there’s a safe way to proceed, but mistakes may come at a high cost if we can’t put the genie back into the bottle if something goes wrong. “If we lose sight of the true gravity of extinction and overzealously embrace de-extinction as a mitigation tool, it would be really easy to manufacture forests, savannas, and oceans full of Franken-species and Eco-zombies,” McCauley says.
But in spite of any danger, McCauley says his biggest concern isn’t a runaway genetic experiment wreaking havoc on a fragile ecosystem. “Honestly, the thing that scares me most is that the public absorbs the misimpression that extinction is no longer scary,” he says. “That the mindset becomes: Deforest, no biggie, we can reforest. If we drive something extinct, no biggie, we can de-extinct it.”
Introducing (or reintroducing) a new species to a habitat always comes with some risk, but de-extinction scientists point out that we’ve been able to manage that risk successfully with living animals like reintroducing wolves into Yellowstone National Park or beavers into the United Kingdom. There have also been disasters, like the poisonous cane toad in Australia, which was originally imported to help control the gray-backed cane beetles that were damaging sugar crops, but is now spreading across the continent and depleting native populations.
“De-extinction is just the next step in a progression that conservation has already been on,” Novak says. “If you want to restore the ecological function of an extinct species, and you don’t have any living species that will do that, you take the closest living species you can get and adapt it based on the genome of the extinct species.”
IUCN has been dealing with these sorts of issues for years now, and so stands uniquely poised to help regulate de-extinction science’s future. Still, there are no laws requiring that researchers take its advice. The only legal structures governing de-extinction are borrowed from genetically modified organism and cloning research—fields regulated by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Department of Agriculture, and Environmental Protection Agency.
Regardless, de-extinction is speeding closer to reality, and now is the time to start thinking about it, McCauley says. “For a long time it was easy to just put it aside because the technology wasn’t there,” he says. “But I don’t think we can do that anymore.”