
The hominin family tree is frequently revised, but researchers disagree
about where many fossils should be placed on the tree. Credit: K.
Cantner, AGI.
As the sole surviving species of the genus
Homo, we
Homo sapiens
are one of the most taxonomically lonely species living on Earth today.
But dig back a few thousand years or more and we find ourselves with
plenty of company: Many now-extinct species shared the genus
Homo, ranging from the robust
Homo neanderthalensis, to the hobbit-like
Homo floresiensis to the more primitive
Homo habilis and
Homo erectus. But do all these species, with their wide diversity of physical and cultural traits, actually belong in the same genus?
Traditionally, hominin fossils have been classified into either the genus
Homo or
Australopithecus, with
Homo
dating back to about 2.8 million years and the oldest Australopiths
dating back to about 4 million years ago. But some anthropologists think
we need more options. “Right now, we are stuck in a false dichotomy,
where if it isn’t an Australopith, it must be
Homo and if it isn’t
Homo, it must be an Australopith,” says
Ian Tattersall,
a paleoanthropologist at the American Museum of Natural History in New
York City. “We obviously need more genera if our classification of
hominins is to meaningfully reflect the diversity within our family.”
But reparsing the hominin family tree is easier said than done.
“This problem is just as much philosophical as taxonomical,” Tattersall
says. “We’re wrestling with nothing less than human exceptionalism” —
the idea that humans are so distinct from other organisms that the rules
of taxonomy don’t apply to us, a problem that has plagued
paleoanthropology from its earliest discoveries. “
Homo has
become a wastebasket of names with very little meaning,” Tattersall
says. “And yet, we’re so emotionally attached to those names that even
people who think they should be changed are unable to agree on how to go
about it.” Nonetheless, some are trying.
What’s in a Name?
In the mid-1700s, Swedish botanist Carl Linnaeus proposed a binomial
naming system to classify organisms according to relatedness and shared
characteristics. This organizational system evolved into the familiar
ranks of kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus and species.
A species is loosely defined as a population of organisms that can
successfully breed. But things get a little more contrived at the genus
level, which is less rooted in biology and more in the scientific drive
for organization. “Species have a reasonably objective biological
reality that is grounded in the dynamic that exists among their
members,” Tattersall
wrote in the journal Inference in February 2016. “Genera, on the other hand, are purely historical constructs,” he wrote.
“A genus is like a make of car,” says
Bernard Wood,
a paleoanthropologist at George Washington University in Washington,
D.C. All Toyotas are more closely related to each other than to any
other make of car and they’re all derived from the original Toyota,
which was made in the 1930s, he adds. A grouping made up of “all the
four-wheel-drive cars made by Toyota would make a sensible genus,” Wood
says. “But a grouping of four-wheel-drive cars made by different
companies would not qualify, even if they look alike and drive alike,
since they don’t share a common ancestor.”

Three-dimensional skull casts of early hominins (left to right):
Australopithecus africanus, 2.5 million years old from Sterkfontein in
South Africa; Homo rudolfensis, 1.9 million years old from Koobi Fora,
Kenya; Homo erectus, 1 million years old from Java, Indonesia; Homo
heidelbergensis, 350,000 years old from Thessalonika, Greece; and Homo
sapiens, 4,800 years old from Fish Hoek, South Africa. Credit:
Smithsonian Institution.
Genera are not as easy to define when it comes to living organisms,
however, especially those as complicated and poorly represented in the
fossil record as early hominins. Prior to the mid-1900s,
paleoanthropologists used taxonomic names to refer to particular fossil
specimens, and by the mid-20th century they had racked up more than a
dozen different genera, most of which were actually the same species:
Homo neanderthalensis.
“The first paleontologists were experts in anatomy, not taxonomy,”
Tattersall says. “They were tuned in to these minor [anatomical]
differences between specimens and named them not only as separate
species, but entirely different genera.”
In 1963, taxonomist and ornithologist Ernst Mayr tried to set
everybody straight by dragging the field in the opposite direction.
“Mayr was the original lumper,” says
Jeff Schwartz,
a physical anthropologist at the University of Pittsburgh. Mayr was
known as the leading architect of the new evolutionary synthesis, which
held that evolution was a gradual process where species gave rise to the
next through natural selection in a neatly linear fashion.
Despite never having seen a hominin fossil, Mayr declared there was only one genus in the hominin family —
Homo — and that there were only three species, each giving way to the next in an orderly fashion:
Homo transvaalensis (roughly equivalent to what we call Australopiths today) gave rise to
Homo erectus, which paved the way for
Homo sapiens to populate the planet.
“Mayr grouped members simply on the basis of bipedalism: everything bipedal was automatically
Homo.
He never looked at fossils and never looked at the literature,”
Schwartz says. “It’s mind-boggling that the field of paleoanthropology
is still being influenced to this day by a nonpaleoanthropologist. We’ve
effectively been mired in Mayr’s misunderstanding since 1963.”
How Do You Define Homo?

When Carl Linnaeaus proposed a binomial naming system, he gave each
plant and animal at least one qualifying characteristic that set them
apart, but for humans, he wrote “Know thyself.” And to this day, “Homo
sapiens” has not been properly defined, researchers say. In 1769,
anatomist Johann Friedrich Blumenbach compiled a list including a chin,
small jaws, small canines abutting small incisors, a large braincase
balanced atop a vertical vertebral column, erect posture, bipedalism, a
bowl-shaped pelvic girdle, buttocks and a long thumb. In 1963, Ernst
Mayr lumped all hominins into the same genus: Homo. More recently,
paleoanthropologists tend to use one or more of four criteria to include
hominins as members of Homo, as shown above. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI.
When Linnaeus was laying out his case for a binomial naming system, he
bestowed Latin genus and species names on a number of plants and
animals, including humans. For each plant and animal, he gave at least
one qualifying characteristic that set them apart, but for humans, he
simply wrote, “Nosce te ipsum,” or “Know thyself.”
“To this day,
Homo sapiens have not been properly defined,” Tattersall says, despite being the type fossil for
Homo.
Attempts to do so usually result in a grab bag of features that
distinguish us from other mammals. In 1795, anatomist Johann Friedrich
Blumenbach compiled a list including a chin, small jaws, small canines
abutting small incisors, a large braincase balanced atop a vertical
vertebral column, erect posture, bipedalism, a bowl-shaped pelvic
girdle, buttocks and a long thumb.
Without a formal definition for even
Homo sapiens,
determining which fossils should fit into the genus is tricky, Wood
says. “We’re looking for fossil species that are not identical to modern
humans but are not so different from modern humans that you would want
to put them in a different adaptive group.” Adaptive groups are made up
of related organisms that share similar adaptations and lifestyles —
such as marine mammals. “Arguments arise when you talk about how far
away from modern humans you can get in terms of morphology while still
maintaining an argument of adaptive coherence,” he says.
Paleoanthropologists have traditionally used one or more of four criteria to include hominins as members of
Homo:
an adult brain size of more than 600 cubic centimeters; limb, hand and
foot proportions similar to modern humans; the ability to communicate
through language; and the ability to manufacture stone tools. “However,
none of these criteria are very satisfactory,” Tattersall says,
especially since they have each been stretched and distorted repeatedly
over the years to accommodate newly discovered fossils.
Brain size was the original preferred defining feature for
Homo, says paleoanthropologist
Rick Potts,
director of the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program at the National
Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C. “Brain size was fairly
easy to measure, even given only fragments of the skull, and it
presented a nice, linear trend: As
Homo got more sophisticated, brain size got bigger.” But while brain size is useful in defining the later members of
Homo, drawing the line between Australopiths and the earliest members of
Homo is difficult. “Early members of the genus
Homo had fairly small brains that overlapped with the brain size of
Australopithecus,” Potts says. “If you’re going to define the genus
Homo at its branching point from Australopiths, brain size is not the best way to do it.”

One of the traditional ways to distinguish Homo from other genuses is
by brain size. Homo has an adult brain size of more than 600 cubic
centimeters. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI, after Shultz and Mason, 2013.
Proportions of the limbs, hands and feet offer more clear-cut measurements to distinguish early
Homo
from Australopiths, which were smaller in stature and had limbs, hands
and feet that were still geared toward an arboreal lifestyle in the
trees. “For Australopiths, becoming bipedal was a real defining
feature,” says
Fred Spoor, a paleoanthropologist at the University College London in England. But limb proportions are quite similar between species of
Homo, making it difficult to differentiate species based on their proportions. “Once we start seeing the modern body plan in early
Homo, it’s difficult to draw the line between one species and another based simply on the limb proportions.”
Spoken language is another criterion that could be used to distinguish
Homo,
but while endocranial casts can offer some clues for the development of
the language centers of the brain, definitive physical evidence for the
origin of complex spoken language is thin. “All we can do is to look at
the archaeological record and make inferences about whether speech
would have been necessary for their level of culture and society,” Wood
says. “That’s a long chain of inference so I’m reluctant to use complex
spoken language as a criterion for
Homo.”

The ability to manufacture stone tools is a common way to differentiate
Homo from other hominins. These handaxes are from early hominins. Left
to right: Africa (1.6 million years old), Asia (1.1 million years old),
and Europe (250,000 years old). Credit: Chip Clark, Smithsonian
Institution.
In the 1960s, the idea of defining
Homo according to tool
use was very much in vogue. “‘Man the toolmaker’ was an interesting
notion at the time, but like a lot of interesting notions, it’s a
hypothesis that has probably been refuted,” Wood says. “The tool use
criterion is not very helpful because it’s quite likely that
Australopithecus
also used tools. Even chimps use tools, though they are less adept at
actually making tools, but it seems like the cognitive basis for tool
use was present in the common ancestor of chimps and modern humans.”
Over the years, people have proposed alternative criteria for defining
Homo,
some more helpful than others. Tooth size is fairly useful, especially
since teeth are some of the most commonly preserved parts of the
skeleton. “Early hominins had much larger teeth than we do relative to
our body size,” Wood says.
Paranthropus, for example, is a genus of early hominins distinguished by their significantly larger teeth — so large the first specimen of
Paranthropus boisei,
discovered in 1959, was nicknamed “Nutcracker Man.” As early hominins
developed stone tools, they were able to process foods outside the mouth
and the selection for large teeth diminished.
Others have proposed using developmental growth as a criterion, as
humans and apes have very different growth patterns. “Modern humans have
a childhood and a prolonged growth period, but if you look at chimps,
they go from being infants to young adults in a number of weeks,” Wood
says.
Perhaps the most radical idea for grouping species into genera is on
the basis of time, with lines drawn between species based on when they
evolved and how long they survived. “It’s a perfectly logical solution
to the problem,” says
Mark Collard,
an anthropologist at Simon Fraser University in Burnaby, British
Columbia. “But one of the consequences is that we end up with modern
chimps and gorillas being classified as
Homo. I don’t think
many people in the field feel comfortable with that, though I’m not sure
they’re willing or able to articulate why.”
Not all paleoanthropologists agree that the genus
Homo
needs to be changed or redefined. Some see the creation of more genera
as merely overcomplicating an arbitrary naming system. “When we talk
about how species should be in a genus or a family, it’s kind of like
asking, ‘How high is up?’” says
Brian Villmoare,
a paleoanthropologist at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. “Nature
does its thing. It finds new niches and lineages split. We’ve invented
this system of taxonomy for organizational purposes and it’s essentially
arbitrary,” Villmoare says. Creating new genera doesn’t add new
information; rather, it just adds demarcations “somewhere on a
continuum,” he says. “I don’t see the value in that.”
Rebranding Homo

Comparison of skull features of replicas of Homo habilis (1.8 million
years old, from Koobi Fora, Kenya), Homo erectus (1.8 million years old,
from Dmanisi, Georgia), Homo floresiensis (from Liang Bua, Flores,
Indonesia, perhaps 20,000 years old) and Homo naledi (age unknown, from
South Africa). Actual fragments of Homo naledi material were overlaid on
a virtual reconstruction. Credit: Chris Stringer, eLIFE, September
2015, CC BY 4.0.
If scientists were going to rebrand
Homo, who would be “in” and who would be “out”? “I would allow
Homo erectus in, but I would draw the line at
Homo habilis,” Wood says.
Homo habilis is the original problem child of the paleoanthropological community. Described in 1964 by
Louis Leakey and colleagues, the team named their find the “handy man” in reference to a
collection
of stone tools found in association with the fossils, which dated to
about 1.75 million years ago. At the time, the “man the toolmaker”
hypothesis was in vogue, with many paleoanthropologists enthralled with
the idea that tool use should be the defining feature of the genus
Homo.

Homo sapiens skull features, for comparison. Credit: K. Cantner, AGI; skull: ©iStockphoto.com/Chinnasorn Pangcharoen.
But
Homo habilis is more similar in size and body type to
Australopithecus.
The original fossil described by Leakey had a brain slightly bigger
than the average Australopith, but the brains of subsequent specimens
have been smaller, between 340 and 500 cubic centimeters. “If you
include
Homo habilis in
Homo, you end up including a species that had limb proportions that are closer to
Australopithecus, as well as dentition and a jaw whose scaling in relation to body mass is closer to
Australopithecus and a brain size closer to
Australopithecus,” Wood says. “A good place to draw the line” is between Australopiths and
Homo, he says, adding that
Homo rudolfensis, a species known from a handful of fossils found in Kenya, should also be left out of genus
Homo.
However, just because
Homo habilis does not belong in
Homo doesn’t mean it’s an Australopith, Tattersall says. “My sense is that
Homo habilis should belong to its own genus, neither Australopith nor human,” he says. “Chucking out
Homo habilis makes sense because it makes
Homo a morphological mess. It certainly tidies up the [
Homo] genus, but stuffing it into
Australopithecus just reinforces this notion that if something is not an Australopith it has to be
Homo
and vice versa. We need a bit more taxonomic elbow room to express the
simple variety of morphology we see in the hominin fossil record.”
But this problem won’t necessarily be solved simply by coining a new
name. “We need a whole new approach,” Schwartz says. “I say we start
from scratch. Forget the names. Once you give something a name, you and
the specimen are stuck with it. Instead of deciding how many new genera
we need from the beginning, let’s start with the fossils, like you would
with any other species,” Schwartz says.
A large part of the problem is that paleoanthropologists are
unwilling to rebrand fossils that have already been named, Tattersall
says. “Anybody who has tried to rename an existing fossil that has
already been described has had a very hard time being taken seriously,”
he says. The only person who has proposed a new genus lately for a
fossil between Australopiths and
Homo is
Meave Leakey, who coined the genus
Kenyanthropus for a new species she discovered in northern Kenya in 1999. “She knew it wasn’t
Homo
and it wasn’t an Australopith either so she came to the logical
conclusion that it was something else. She got away with it because she
had a new fossil, but she got dumped on considerably for it.”
Younger fossils are also trapped in a dichotomy, where if it isn’t a Neanderthal, it must be a
Homo sapiens, Schwartz says. “Until about 20,000 years ago, there were Neanderthals and
Homo sapiens and after then there were only
Homo sapiens. But we’re finding a lot of variants in Asia, particularly China and Indonesia, and we keep classifying everything as
Homo,
regardless of what they look like,” he says. “A different picture is
emerging of a lot more diversity in Asia in recent times than we see in
Europe and Africa. And we need to stop lumping everything into
Homo sapiens if we’re going to explore that diversity properly.”
The problem is highlighted by the so-called hobbits found on the
Indonesian island of Flores in 2003. Standing just over a meter tall
with small brains and large teeth, the hobbits defy the classical
definition of
Homo, and yet they have been classified as
Homo floresiensis. “It’s really problematic, assigning those hobbits to
Homo,
when we’re talking about something that’s a meter tall, with a tiny
brain by hominin standards,” Collard says. “It’s very difficult to see
how that doesn’t stretch the boundaries of the genus
Homo beyond what should be reasonable.”
Beating Around the Bush

Paleoanthropologists argue about whether Homo floresiensis, which stood
just about a meter tall and had a much smaller brain than modern Homo
sapiens, but lived very recently, should be classified as Homo. Homo
floresiensis remains have been found in the Liang Bua Cave on the
Indonesian island of Flores. Credit: Liang Bua Team.
In the 18th century, when Linnaeus christened mankind as the genus Homo,
people didn’t think humans had a fossil record. The history of our
species was rooted in the creation story, not evolution. But nearly 300
years later, paleoanthropology is still tiptoeing around the imaginary
boundary between humans and animals. “This issue plays into several
big-picture, profound and philosophical questions that
paleoanthropologists are often unconsciously butted up against,” Collard
says. “It’s something we’ve struggled with for hundreds of years. Not
just in paleoanthropology but also Western science and philosophy.”
The problem is thrown into a harsher light when comparing the classification of
Homo
with any other animal group, Spoor says. “For a paleontologist who
studies any other animal group, there would be no hesitation to give new
genus names to groups of species to comply with the rules of taxonomy.
Within human evolution, these rules are constantly being violated.”
For example, before molecular testing, paleontologists could only
speculate where whales and dolphins should fit into the mammalian family
tree. “Then genetics came along and showed they are most closely
related to hippos and even-toed ungulates, and the entire order was
reclassified to reflect that radical shift with very little controversy
or resistance,” Spoor says. “However, in human evolution, we’re so
sensitive to creating scandal and even minor confusion that there’s
great reluctance, even in papers that beautifully address this problem,
to offer solutions.”
In the future, genetics may offer deeper insights into the
relatedness of hominin species, but currently, the technology is
limited, especially when analyzing older fossils. “A decade ago, we
didn’t think there could be a Neanderthal genome project and now there
is,” Potts says. “Who knows where that technology will take our genus in
the future.”
Until then, paleoanthropologists will keep working on finding new
fossils and placing them within the branches of the human family tree,
which gets more bush-like with every new discovery. “Sometimes new
fossils bring more clarity and sometimes they bring more confusion,”
Wood says. “We will need to keep getting smarter about how we interpret
these fossils, how we view our ancestors and how we view ourselves.”